We’re facing a strange energy paradox right now. On one hand, the demand for electricity in the U.S. is set to skyrocket, thanks in large part to the massive data centers needed to power the AI revolution. On the other, federal policy is dialing back support for wind and solar power. It’s a contradiction you can’t miss: to lead in AI and be energy independent, we need huge amounts of cheap power. But we’re making it harder to build some of the cheapest and fastest sources of that power.
To make sense of this puzzle, I sat down with Professor Michael Gerrard for this week’s episode of A Climate Change. As the founder of the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia Law School, he has been in the thick of environmental law for decades—as a lawyer, a scholar, and someone who literally writes the model laws for others to use.
Here are some of the biggest takeaways from our conversation.
From Polluted Air to a Career in Law
Gerrard’s story starts not in a courtroom, but in Charleston, West Virginia, surrounded by petrochemical pollution. He was a student at Columbia for the very first Earth Day in 1970 and ended up writing his senior thesis on the politics of air pollution. After a stint with an environmental group, he didn’t just stumble into environmental law; he went to law school with a mission.
He spent 30 years in the field, first at a small firm fighting for the environment and later at a large one, before moving into academia in 2009. That’s when he founded the Sabin Center at Columbia with a clear vision:
Create new legal strategies to tackle climate change.
Train the next wave of lawyers who will fight these battles.
Make legal information and resources available to everyone.
The Lawyer’s Toolkit: What to Do When Congress Won’t Act
Ideally, Congress would pass a big, sweeping climate bill. That hasn’t happened.
So, in the meantime, climate action in the U.S. leans on three main pillars:
Using existing laws, like the Clean Air Act, to regulate emissions.
Going to court, often to defend those regulations from challenges.
Action from states, which are stepping up where the federal government hasn’t.
The bedrock for much of this is the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Massachusetts v. EPA. That case established that the EPA has the power—and maybe even the duty—to regulate greenhouse gases as air pollutants.
But that bedrock authority is now facing a serious threat.
The “Major Questions” Doctrine and a Looming Fight
The Trump administration has made it clear they want to re-examine the EPA’s authority to regulate climate pollution. A likely line of attack will be the “major questions doctrine,” which the Supreme Court used in cases like West Virginia v. EPA. The basic idea is that for issues with huge economic and political importance, a government agency needs very explicit permission from Congress to act.
Gerrard calls the current legal strategy against the EPA a “cluster bomb”—they’re throwing multiple arguments at the wall, hoping one will stick and gut the agency’s power.
The defenders of the EPA will point out that the Clean Air Act was written broadly to protect public “health or welfare,” and “welfare” was defined to include impacts on the climate. Congress knew about greenhouse gases back in 1970. The big question is whether today’s Supreme Court will agree that’s enough.
A Win in Montana: How State Courts Are Different
While things look tough at the federal level, the story is different in the states.
In Montana, a group of young people successfully sued the state over a law that prevented officials from considering climate change when approving new projects. The court sided with the kids, basing its decision on a right to a clean and healthful environment written right into Montana’s constitution.
The victory was smart and strategic. It didn’t demand a total overhaul of the state’s energy system, but it established a crucial legal principle. This targeted approach has worked better than broader lawsuits, like the *Juliana v. United States* case, which have had a much harder time in federal courts.
Taking on the Fossil Fuel Industry
Meanwhile, a wave of lawsuits is hitting the fossil fuel industry itself. Over 30 states, cities, and territories are suing major oil companies, and many of these cases are finally moving forward.
In Massachusetts, for instance, the case is built around consumer fraud, arguing that these companies deliberately misled the public about the climate risks of their products. In Puerto Rico, a lawsuit is using RICO laws, typically associated with organized crime, to go after the industry. A key battleground in these trials will be “attribution science”—the ability to link specific damages, like a hurricane’s intensity, to a specific company’s emissions.
The oil companies have largely stopped denying climate change outright. Instead, their argument has gotten more sophisticated. They claim that emissions are a global problem, that they just supply the fuel that consumers burn, and that you can’t blame any single storm on climate change.
Building a Greener Future, One Local Law at a Time
Gerrard isn’t just focused on litigation; he’s also building the tools for a solution. He co-edited a massive guide called Legal Pathways to Deep Decarbonization, which is essentially a recipe book with over 1,000 legal recommendations for cutting emissions.
His team at the Sabin Center is now turning those ideas into ready-to-use model laws that state and local governments can adopt. With the federal government pulling back, action from states and cities is more important than ever. We’re already seeing progress in areas like:
Greener building codes.
Requirements for rooftop solar on new buildings.
Tougher energy efficiency standards.
The Politics of a Carbon Price
Of course, even the best policies can run into political roadblocks. States are still trying out market-based solutions, but it can be a tough sell.
New York’s “cap-and-invest” plan, a type of cap-and-trade system, was suddenly put on hold by Governor Hochul, sparking a lawsuit from environmental groups. The episode highlights a classic problem: policies that make the price of gas go up are politically toxic, even if they work.
On the other hand, New York City’s congestion pricing program, which charges drivers to enter the busiest parts of Manhattan, has been a success so far—cutting traffic and speeding up buses—despite facing its own political hurdles.
The Energy Paradox: When Politics and Markets Collide
This brings us back to the paradox we started with. Federal policy is full of contradictions: we’re supporting fossil fuels, but lower energy prices actually discourage new drilling. Wind and solar are the cheapest and fastest ways to add new electricity, but we’re making them harder to build. Meanwhile, there are backlogs for the natural gas turbines we’d need, and new nuclear power plants take forever to get online.
If the AI boom really does cause a surge in electricity demand, the market itself may push us toward renewables, no matter what politicians say. The question is whether our leaders will listen to those signals.
A Global View: Human Rights and Climate Justice
Looking beyond the U.S., you can see courts around the world getting much more involved.
The International Court of Justice recently issued a powerful advisory opinion, framing the fight against climate change as a fundamental human rights issue. And in countries like the Netherlands, Germany, Pakistan, and Brazil, domestic courts have ordered their own governments to take stronger action on climate.
The United States is an outlier. We don’t have a right to a clean environment in our Constitution, we haven’t fully incorporated human rights treaties into our laws, and our current judiciary is deeply skeptical of giving government agencies too much power.
What It All Comes Down To
So, what’s the bottom line? Gerrard pointed out two things that are happening at once: legal creativity is flourishing at the state and local levels, but at the same time, federal policy is putting the brakes on clean energy right when we need it most.
For all the legal maneuvering, Gerrard left me with a crucial reminder: the real battle is in the voting booth. Courts can protect the laws we already have, but building a lasting climate policy requires getting the President and Congress on the same page.
Resources
To learn more about the work we do at A Climate Change—including our goal of planting 30,000 trees in the Amazon this year—visit aclimatechange.com. You can also subscribe on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.



The money wins, every time.